The Very Best Of Us And The Very Worst

The Very Best Of Us And The Very Worst

I take no joy in writing what I’m about to write. I take no pleasure in saying what I’m about to say. I take no satisfaction, no pride and no honour either, and yet I feel I have to say it anyway.

Because today I read a story that will disgust you and will repulse you and will sicken you and send tremors of anger down your spine.

It is the story about how 5 American Jewish women decided to spit in the face of their ancestors and to mock their Jewish heritage and to hold in contempt everything of value that any proud Jew in the world feels.

It started when these 5 women, who were members of IfNotNow – a self-hating Jewish group, managed to sign up for a Taglit-Birthright trip to Israel. Taglit-Birthright is a movement designed to give Diaspora Jewry a greater understanding of their roots by organising free trips to Israel.

Except, in what was obviously a planned stunt, these activists decided to leave the trip very abruptly and very publicly to join a radical left wing group in Israel called Breaking the Silence.
It was also reported that this group had tried to recruit departing Birthright participants from New York’s Kennedy Airport, telling them that Birthright was “working against Jewish morality.”

Now, as much as I’m angry – and I am, I am also sad, because we are living at a time in history when there are physical and violent attacks against Jews across Israel and the entire world. We are living at a time in history when the very legitimacy of the State of Israel is being challenged and therefore the very legitimacy of the Jewish people to live freely as well and this includes them.

Hate-Mailer Response

And yet, they have turned their backs on their own people, beaming with pride as they advocate for their own destruction. They have traded in their Judaism for some kind of false liberalism in an effort to be liked by others, and to fit in with their skewered and warped social justice world. Except this world in which they are so desperate to be a part see them as nothing more than useful idiots who ultimately will be cast out too.

And on a day where we celebrate the very best of us in the first all-female tank crew graduation in Israel, we also see the very worst of us in them. Jewish women of similar ages, yet half of them do everything they can to protect our precious Jewish existence, while the other half do everything they can to destroy it.

Sadly, they are symbolic of a dysfunctional society in which too many American Jews no longer see themselves as Jews, but as some kind of “social justice warriors” who only use their Judaism to score extra points in their anarchist circles. They don’t care about their heritage, or their history, or their culture or any of those things that have bound the Jewish people across the world over thousands of years of time.

The only solace I take is that, because they don’t care about who they are, they will assimilate very quickly and with intermarriage rates of something like 70% in the United States, we can be quite sure that in a generation or two they would have faded away into the cloudy mists of time – leaving the Jewish people forever.

But there remains a hollow feeling about this, because to be a Jew is a gift – an honour really, one that I would not sacrifice for anything – and to see that honour squandered and outsourced to the very heart of our enemies desires is something that I will always struggle to come to terms with.

So while they celebrate the hatred they espouse for their own people, there’s something they should know, because unlike them there are Jews who are proud of their heritage and are proud of their Jewish state and who have made so many sacrifices to ensure that state’s survival. There are young men and women who lay their lives on the line each second of each minute of each hour of each day, so that these women can live as Jews in an existence of freedom. And while they can stand on busses and hills and shout well-rehearsed slogans, there are also those of us who can also shout, but not slogans of hatred – slogans of pride and of love and of joy at how much we love our State of Israel and our Jewish people.

Perhaps it is our destiny to be cursed with external enemies and internal ones too, but it is also our destiny to be a people with a strong will and a strong desire to always continue onwards on that journey of life.


  1. Sandalina Rachel

    I couldn’t agree with you more, Justin Amler. It angers me because they planned to take advantage of a wonderful organization that was generous enough to provide them with a free trip to Israel, and they attempted to convince others, who were enjoying their good fortune to leave with them, and to stupidly travel to Arab destinations .Then they had the nerve to complain and whine because Birthright did not provide their transportation home!!! Shame on them!! I have a very hard time understanding what is happening to American Jewry, and especially to their generation, which as you so aptly said, will not even consider themselves as Jews years from now as they become more assimilated.

  2. philip.sheaf@ntlworld .com

    these five unfortunately are not the only ones that have turned their backs on their Jewish heritage , I hear and see how devastating assimilation is , insidiously bending their minds away from Jewish thinking until their logic is based on non Jewish logic , of course then one and one equals two , no extra Jewish dimension , they do not realise how easily this has been stolen from them , will they ever regret it , no one knows . the biggest problem Jews have as a people in the “free” world is the battle to win the “hearts and minds” of the younger generation so that they can integrate but not assimilate , there has been some success but at the present time it seems a losing battle but the Jewish people are mainly optimists by nature , that is a key feature of our survival , boruch ata adoshem.

  3. Hadar

    I agree with you Julian these five traitorous women deserve the contempt of Israel et al but of course being who we are we understand their self-loathing. I pity them and their dismal behaviour!
    They, of course, should be accountable for expenses!!!!

  4. Deborah

    Well written, not sure if this drama of self hatred is more sad or infuriating. Didn’t realize until reading this that the departure from
    Birthright was staged and planned well before their departure…..
    They should be held accountable for not only expenses of the trip, but for libel and false pretenses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *